Proposed legislation on publishing police photographs sparks protests throughout France


Hundreds of individuals took to the streets in Paris and different French cities Saturday on the urging of civil liberties campaigners and journalist teams to protest a proposed safety legislation they are saying would impinge on freedom of knowledge and media rights.

Pending laws in France’s parliament would create a brand new felony offence for publishing photographs of law enforcement officials with intent to trigger them hurt. Offenders would face a most penalty of as much as one yr in jail and a €45,000 positive (about $69,000 Cdn).

The federal government mentioned the proposal is meant to guard law enforcement officials from on-line requires violence. Critics concern that, if enacted, the measure would endanger journalists and different observers who take movies of officers at work, particularly throughout violent demonstrations.

In Paris, a number of thousand demonstrators gathered on the Trocadero sq. close to the Eiffel Tower, chanting “Freedom, freedom” and “Everybody needs to movie the police.”


Police used water cannons to disperse the gang as minor scuffles broke out on the finish of the demonstration. Paris police mentioned 23 folks had been detained and an officer was barely injured.

Reporters with out Borders, Amnesty Worldwide France, the Human Rights League, journalists’ unions and different teams inspired folks to attend the protest. The gang included many journalists and college students.

“We’re not right here to defend a privilege of our occupation, press freedom and journalists’ freedom,” Edwy Plenel, co-founder and editor of investigative web site Mediapart, mentioned. “We’re right here to defend elementary rights, the rights of all folks.”

Some members of the anti-government yellow vest motion additionally joined the demonstration.

The Workplace of the United Nations Excessive Commissioner for Human Rights and France’s human rights ombudsman have additionally voiced issues that the brand new provision may undermine elementary rights.


PM’s modification announcement not sufficient, critic says

In response to the criticism, Prime Minister Jean Castex mentioned Thursday that the measure can be amended to specify that it “will not impede the liberty of knowledge” and that it’s going to focus solely on photographs broadcast with “clear” intent to hurt a police officer.

Emmanuel Poupard, secretary common of the Nationwide Journalists Union, mentioned Saturday that he thinks the brand new modification “would not change something.”

The police picture legislation “has just one objective: to spice up the sense of impunity of legislation enforcement officers and make invisible police brutality,” he mentioned.

French gendarmes stand in entrance of the Eiffel Tower to stop protesters from approaching the monument. (Charles Platiau/Reuters)

Protesters argue that recording officers in motion is crucial to having the ability to condemn and curb the actions of violent officers. In addition they fear how courts would decide whether or not photographs had been posted with intent to hurt.


In July, three French law enforcement officials had been charged with manslaughter over the demise of a supply man, Cedric Chouviat, that bystanders caught on video. Chouviat’s demise had similarities with the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis, which sparked outrage all over the world and a sequence of Black Lives Matter demonstrations in France.

The proposed legislation is championed by lawmakers from President Emmanuel Macron’s occasion, which has a majority within the Nationwide Meeting.

Lawmakers are scheduled to vote Tuesday on the invoice, which additionally consists of different safety measures. It is going to then go to the Senate.

Source link


Leave a Comment